Fault Analysis and Improvement of Worm Gear Reducer for Mining Shuttle Car

1. Worm Gear Reducer Structure and Parameters

ParameterValue
Drive ModeMotor
Input Power24 kW
Input Speed1420 r/min
Input Torque161 N·m
Transmission Ratio34.6 (Gear Ratio , Worm Gear Ratio )

2. Faults in Worm Gear Reducer

FaultCause
Severe Heat and Oil LeakageSliding friction in worm gear transmission generates heat, causing expansion and potential sealing issues.
Severe Wear of Worm GearPoor meshing and lubrication lead to increased wear.

3. Research on Worm Gear Reducer

3.1 Worm Gear Materials

NameMaterial GradeUsage Characteristics and Application Range
Worm20, 15Cr, 20Cr, 20CrMnTi, 20CrMnMo
40Cr, 40CrNi, 35SiMn, 35CrMo, 38SiMnMo, 40CrNiMo
ZCuSn10Pb1, ZCuSn5Pb5Zn5
Carburizing and quenching (56 – 62HRC) grinding, for high-speed heavy-duty transmission
Quenching (45 – 55HRC) grinding, for high-speed heavy-duty transmission
Strong anti-scuffing ability, low mechanical strength, expensive, for large sliding speed ( m/s) and long-term continuous work
Worm GearZCuAl10Fe3, ZCuAl10Fe3Mn2, ZCuZn38Mn2Pb2, ZCuSn12Ni2Weak anti-scuffing ability, high mechanical strength, requires surface hardening of mating worm, cheap, for medium sliding speed ( m/s)

Selected Materials: Worm – 38CrMoAl (quenched and tempered nitride), Worm Gear – ZCuSn12Ni2.

3.2 Surface Quality of Worm Gear

  • Entrust processing to advanced enterprises.
  • Establish strict quality management system.
  • Ensure surface roughness and tooth thickness tolerance of worm within design range.

3.3 Assembly of Worm Gear

FactorRequirement
Center DistanceEnsure within design range using coordinate measuring instrument.
LubricationWorm gear immersion depth is 1/3 of outer diameter, use special lubricating oil, and ensure oil quality.
Assembly ClearanceControl side clearance between 0.38 – 0.45 mm.
Assembly ErrorContact spot area along tooth length ≥60%, along tooth height ≥65%, and biased towards tooth surface exit.

3.4 Lubrication of Worm Gear

  • Good lubrication can form oil film, reduce wear, and improve transmission efficiency.
  • The worm gear reducer requires lubricant with good properties.

4. Tests

4.1 Bench Test

  • Test Bed: Can collect various data and display transmission efficiency.
  • Test Time: 40 s loading (full load), 5 min idle, for 4 days (8 h/day).
  • Test Conclusion:
    • Oil temperature is about 30 °C higher than shell temperature. Consider using high-temperature resistant seals.
    • Transmission efficiency is 75% – 80%. Can use a gear reducer with 80% of the original transmission ratio.
    • After 4 days of testing, there is copper powder in the gear oil, and the worm gear has slight wear, indicating the running-in stage.

4.2 Underground Industrial Test

  • After 1 week, the reducer is normal, with a small amount of copper powder in the oil, indicating the running-in stage.
  • After 1 month, the reducer is normal, with very little copper powder in the oil, indicating the stable wear stage.
  • After 6 months, the reducer is still normal, verifying the success of the improvement.

5. Conclusion

The worm gear reducer for mining shuttle cars has problems such as high temperature, severe wear, and low service life. By studying factors such as material, surface quality, assembly, and lubrication, and conducting tests, a reducer that can be used normally for more than 6 months has been developed, indicating the success of the development.

Scroll to Top