Optimization of Skiving Tool Modification for Internal Gear Manufacturing

In the field of gear manufacturing, internal gears are critical components used in various mechanical systems, such as planetary gearboxes and automotive transmissions. The production of high-precision internal gears poses significant challenges due to limitations in traditional machining methods like hobbing or shaping, especially for non-through holes or gears without undercuts. Skiving, a high-efficiency and precision machining process, has emerged as a promising solution for internal gear manufacturer. This process combines rolling and cutting motions, enabling continuous generation of gear teeth with minimal setup time. However, the inherent principle errors in skiving tools, arising from their asymmetric cutting edges and complex geometry, often lead to deviations in the final gear tooth surfaces. These errors can affect the performance, noise, and longevity of gears in applications. To address this, we propose a novel modification design method for skiving tools, focusing on reducing principle errors through optimized tooth profile modifications. This approach leverages a rack-cutter-based derivation to model the skiving tool surface and cutting edges, followed by an analysis of tooth surface deviations and optimization techniques. By integrating mathematical modeling, simulation, and practical considerations, our method aims to enhance the accuracy and efficiency of internal gear manufacturer, making it more accessible for industrial applications.

The skiving process for internal gears involves the relative motion between the skiving tool and the workpiece, where the tool rotates and translates along the workpiece axis while maintaining a specific axis crossing angle. This dual-degree-of-freedom (DOF) enveloping process ensures continuous cutting action, but it introduces complexities in tool design. The fundamental kinematics can be described using coordinate systems and transformation matrices. Let \( S_1 \) and \( S_2 \) represent the reference coordinate systems for the workpiece and skiving tool, respectively, with \( S_{1s} \) and \( S_{2s} \) as their dynamic counterparts. The axis crossing angle is denoted by \( \Sigma \), the center distance by \( E \), and the angular velocities of the workpiece and tool by \( \omega_1 \) and \( \omega_2 \). The relationship between these parameters is governed by the equation:

$$ \omega_1 = \frac{z_2}{z_1} \omega_2 – \frac{v_f}{p} $$

where \( z_1 \) and \( z_2 \) are the number of teeth on the workpiece and tool, respectively, \( v_f \) is the feed velocity along the workpiece axis, and \( p \) is the helical parameter. This equation highlights that the workpiece’s angular velocity comprises both the rolling motion relative to the tool and an additional component due to axial feed, which is crucial for achieving the desired tooth geometry in internal gears. The coordinate transformations between these systems facilitate the derivation of tooth surfaces and cutting paths, ensuring accurate modeling of the skiving process for internal gear manufacturer.

To design the skiving tool, we start from a modified rack-cutter, which serves as the basis for generating the continuous shifting skiving tool surface. The rack-cutter’s normal tooth profile includes a parabolic modification to compensate for principle errors. In the coordinate system \( S_t \), associated with the cutting edge, the position vector of a point on the rack-cutter is given by \( \mathbf{r}_t(u_t, l_t) = [a u_t^2, u_t, l_t, 1]^T \), where \( a \) is the parabola modification coefficient, \( u_t \) is the distance from the cutting point to the origin, and \( l_t \) is the parameter along the tooth width. The transformation to the rack-cutter dynamic coordinate system \( S_c \) involves rotation and translation matrices, accounting for the tooth profile angle \( \alpha \) and helical aspects. The unit normal vector \( \mathbf{n}_c(u_t, l_t) \) is derived from the cross product of partial derivatives of \( \mathbf{r}_c \). For internal gear manufacturer, this step ensures that the rack-cutter profile accurately represents the desired gear geometry, including modifications for error reduction.

The generation of the skiving tool surface from the rack-cutter involves the principle of variable shifting in involute gears. The shifting coefficient \( x_{lt} \) varies along the tooth width and is defined as:

$$ x_{lt} = x \cos(\beta) – l_t \tan(\alpha_0 \cos(\beta)) / m_n $$

where \( x \) is the maximum shifting coefficient on the rake face, \( \beta \) is the helix angle, \( \alpha_0 \) is the tool’s relief angle, and \( m_n \) is the normal module. The engagement condition between the rack-cutter and the skiving tool requires that the normal direction at any cutting point passes through the instantaneous center of rotation. This leads to the equation:

$$ \phi = \frac{x_c n_{cy} – y_c n_{cx}}{r_{pt} n_{cx}} $$

where \( \phi \) is the rotation angle of the workpiece, and \( r_{pt} \) is the pitch radius. By eliminating \( \phi \), we obtain the skiving tool tooth surface position vector \( \mathbf{r}_s(u_t, l_t) \) and normal vector \( \mathbf{n}_s(u_t, l_t) \) in the tool’s dynamic coordinate system \( S_s \). These equations form the foundation for designing skiving tools that minimize errors in internal gear manufacturer, as they incorporate continuous shifting and profile modifications.

The cutting edge of the skiving tool is determined by the intersection of the tool tooth surface and the rake face. Unlike standard gear tools, the skiving tool’s rake face is inclined by a rake angle \( \gamma \) and rotated by the helix angle \( \beta \), resulting in asymmetric cutting edges. This asymmetry is a primary source of principle errors in internal gear manufacturer. The reference point on the rake face, typically the midpoint of the top edge, has a position vector \( \mathbf{r}_m \) and a normal vector \( \mathbf{n}_m \). The cutting edge is defined by the system of equations:

$$ \mathbf{n}_m \cdot (\mathbf{r}_s – \mathbf{r}_m) = 0 $$
$$ x_s^2(u_t, l_t) + y_s^2(u_t, l_t) = r^2 $$

where \( r \) is the cutting edge position parameter. The tangent vector \( \mathbf{t}_s \) along the cutting edge is derived from the cross product of \( \mathbf{n}_s \) and \( \mathbf{n}_m \). This mathematical representation allows for precise control over the cutting edge geometry, which is essential for reducing deviations in the manufactured internal gears. By optimizing the parameters such as the rake angle and helix angle, we can mitigate the effects of asymmetry and improve machining accuracy.

In the skiving process for internal gears, the relative motion between the tool and workpiece is modeled using homogeneous coordinate transformations and the double-DOF enveloping theory. The workpiece tooth surface is generated as the envelope of the tool surface during its motion. The position vector \( \mathbf{r}_1(u_t, l_t, \phi_2, v) \) and tangent vector \( \mathbf{t}_1(u_t, l_t, \phi_2, v) \) in the workpiece dynamic coordinate system \( S_1 \) are obtained through successive transformations involving matrices \( M_{2s} \) and \( M_{12} \). The rotation angle of the workpiece \( \phi_1 \) is related to the tool rotation \( \phi_2 \) and axial displacement \( v \) by:

$$ \phi_1 = m_{21} \phi_2 + \frac{2\pi v}{L_g} $$

where \( m_{21} = z_1 / z_2 \) is the gear ratio, and \( L_g = \pi z_2 m_n / \sin \beta \) is the lead of the workpiece. The meshing condition, based on the relative velocity and normal vectors, is expressed as:

$$ \mathbf{n}_1 \cdot (\mathbf{v}_{12}) = 0 $$

where \( \mathbf{v}_{12} \) is the relative velocity vector between the tool and workpiece. Solving this equation, along with the cutting edge and surface equations, yields the tooth surface of the internal gear. This model enables the prediction of tooth surface deviations and facilitates the optimization of tool parameters for internal gear manufacturer.

To validate our approach, we conducted a numerical example comparing different methods for skiving tool design: the formula method, the modified rack-cutter method (our proposed approach), and the reverse envelope method (considered error-free). The basic parameters for the skiving tool and internal gear are summarized in the table below. These parameters are typical for internal gear manufacturer applications and include key dimensions such as module, number of teeth, and helix angles.

Basic Parameters for Skiving Tool and Internal Gear
Parameter Skiving Tool Internal Gear
Pressure Angle (°) 20.00 20.00
Module (mm) 2.00 2.00
Number of Teeth 31 57
Face Width (mm) 10.00 20.00
Helix Angle (°) 15.00 5.00
Maximum Shifting Coefficient 0.25
Relief Angle (°) 6.00

Using these parameters, we derived the skiving tool surface and cutting edge points, which were imported into CAD software to generate a solid model. The cutting edge curves from the formula method, modified rack-cutter method, and reverse envelope method were compared. The reverse envelope method provides an error-free reference, as it directly computes the cutting edge from the desired gear tooth surface. Our analysis showed that the cutting edge from the modified rack-cutter method is closer to the reverse envelope curve than the formula method, indicating reduced principle errors. Specifically, the maximum tooth surface deviation for the formula method was 24 μm, while for the modified rack-cutter method, it was 18 μm. This improvement is attributed to the continuous shifting and profile modifications incorporated in our approach for internal gear manufacturer.

Further optimization was performed by treating the rack-cutter’s profile modification coefficient \( a \) as a variable and minimizing the sum of squared tooth surface deviations. Using a one-dimensional golden section search, we found the optimal value \( a = 0.0012 \). After optimization, the maximum tooth surface deviation decreased to 3 μm, demonstrating a significant reduction in principle errors. However, the deviations remained asymmetric due to the inherent asymmetry of the cutting edges. This highlights the challenge in completely eliminating errors through profile modification alone, as the rake angle and helix angle disproportionately affect the two sides of the cutting edge. For internal gear manufacturer, this optimization step is crucial for achieving high precision in gear teeth, especially in applications requiring tight tolerances.

The mathematical models and optimization techniques presented here provide a comprehensive framework for designing skiving tools for internal gears. The tooth surface equation for the internal gear is derived from the skiving model, incorporating the double-DOF enveloping theory. The general form of the tooth surface can be expressed as a function of parameters \( u_t \), \( l_t \), \( \phi_2 \), and \( v \), solved from the system of nonlinear equations. The deviation between the actual and ideal tooth surfaces is calculated as the Euclidean distance at corresponding points. For internal gear manufacturer, this allows for quantitative assessment of machining accuracy and identification of critical parameters influencing errors.

In conclusion, our proposed modified rack-cutter method for skiving tool design offers a practical and accurate solution for internal gear manufacturer. By starting from a profile-modified rack-cutter and optimizing the modification coefficients, we effectively reduce principle errors that arise from tool asymmetry and complex kinematics. The comparison with traditional methods underscores the superiority of our approach in minimizing tooth surface deviations. However, complete error elimination remains challenging due to the asymmetric nature of the cutting edges, which may require advanced techniques such as spline-based modifications for further improvement. This research contributes to the advancement of gear manufacturing technologies, enabling the production of high-quality internal gears with enhanced efficiency and precision. Future work could explore multi-axis grinding and real-time adaptive control to address residual errors and expand the applicability of skiving in industrial settings for internal gear manufacturer.

The implications of this study extend beyond academic research, offering tangible benefits for internal gear manufacturer in sectors like automotive, aerospace, and heavy machinery. By reducing principle errors, manufacturers can achieve higher gear quality, leading to improved performance and durability of mechanical systems. Moreover, the simplified design and manufacturing process for skiving tools makes this technology more accessible, potentially lowering production costs and increasing adoption. As the demand for precision gears grows, continued innovation in skiving tool design will play a pivotal role in meeting industry standards and driving progress in internal gear manufacturer.

Scroll to Top